Contact Us

The Role of the Court of Protection in Lasting Power of Attorney Cases: Understanding Its Authority and Processes

Published on 
01 May 2025

The Court of Protection plays a key role when it comes to Lasting Power of Attorney (LPA) cases. It steps in to make decisions or appoint deputies if there is a dispute or if the person who made the LPA no longer has the capacity to manage their own affairs. This ensures that decisions are made in the best interest of the person concerned.

You may need the Court of Protection if there are problems with how an attorney is acting under an LPA or if no attorney has been appointed and decisions still need to be made. The court has the authority to resolve these issues and protect your rights or those of your loved ones.

Understanding how the Court of Protection works with LPAs helps you know your options. It is important if you want to plan ahead or if you face challenges with someone acting on your behalf. You can learn more about its specific functions and when it becomes involved.

Learn about the Court of Protection

Understanding Lasting Power of Attorney and the Court of Protection

Knowing how Lasting Powers of Attorney (LPAs) and the Court of Protection work helps you plan for decisions if you lose mental capacity. These rules clarify who can manage your money or welfare and when formal approval is needed.

Differences Between Lasting and Enduring Power of Attorney

You can use an Enduring Power of Attorney (EPA) only for decisions about your property and finances. EPAs can no longer be created but those signed before October 2007 remain valid.

LPAs replaced EPAs and are more comprehensive. There are two types of LPA: one for health and welfare decisions and another for property and financial affairs. LPAs must be registered with the Office of the Public Guardian (OPG) to be used.

An LPA allows the person you choose (attorney) to act on your behalf only when you lose mental capacity. This is different from an EPA, which could be used before mental capacity was lost if you authorised it.

The Mental Capacity Act 2005 and the Role of Capacity Assessment

The Mental Capacity Act 2005 sets the legal framework for making decisions when someone lacks mental capacity. Mental capacity means the ability to understand, retain, and weigh up information to make decisions.

Before an attorney can act, it must be clear that you lack capacity for the decision needed at that time. This assessment can be done by healthcare professionals or others involved in your care.

Your mental capacity is always specific to the time and decision. You may have capacity for some choices but not others. This means attorneys and the Court of Protection act only when you truly cannot decide for yourself.

The Office of the Public Guardian and Regulatory Oversight

The Office of the Public Guardian (OPG) oversees LPAs and deputies appointed by the Court of Protection. They register LPAs to make sure they are valid and keep records.

If you do not have an LPA but can’t make decisions, the Court of Protection can appoint a deputy to manage your affairs. The OPG then supervises the deputy’s work to protect your interests.

The OPG also investigates concerns about the misuse of power by attorneys or deputies. They ensure your rights are respected and that anyone acting for you follows legal rules.

You can find more about this at the Court of Protection - GOV.UK.

How the Court of Protection Intervenes in Lasting Power of Attorney Cases

The Court of Protection plays a vital role when issues arise with Lasting Powers of Attorney (LPAs). It guides the legal process for applications, resolves disagreements, and can change or stop attorney powers to protect your interests.

Application Process and Legal Representatives

If you need the Court of Protection to act regarding an LPA, you or your legal representative must formally apply. This involves filling out specific court forms and providing evidence about the situation and the donor’s capacity. The court often requires detailed reports on the donor’s health to confirm they cannot manage their own affairs.

You may choose to use legal aid to help with costs if you meet eligibility rules. The court may also appoint a legal representative to support the donor if they cannot represent themselves.

The Official Solicitor can become involved if there is no one else to represent the donor’s interests. This officer acts independently to ensure decisions are in the donor's best interest.

Challenges and Disputes Over LPAs

Disputes often arise when family members or others question an attorney’s actions under an LPA. If you believe an attorney is acting improperly or against the donor's wishes, you can ask the Court of Protection to investigate.

These disputes may concern misuse of finances, poor care decisions, or conflicts between attorneys. The court can hear evidence and decide whether the attorney’s behaviour is lawful and in the donor’s best interests.

The court aims to protect the donor by balancing the need for support with safeguards against abuse. It can enforce rules or set conditions on how attorneys operate to reduce risk.

Revocation or Suspension of Attorney Powers

If the Court of Protection finds that an attorney has abused their powers or is failing in their duties, it can suspend or revoke the LPA. This action prevents further harm to the donor’s finances or wellbeing.

You can request the court to revoke an LPA if clear evidence shows misuse or neglect. The court will carefully review all details before making a decision.

During this process, the court may appoint a replacement attorney or deputy to take over responsibilities. This ensures the donor continues to receive support without unnecessary delay.

Revocation is a serious step used only when necessary to protect the donor from harm. You can find more about the court’s authority in Can the Court of Protection revoke a Lasting Power of Attorney?

The Court’s Decision-Making Principles: Best Interests and Capacity

Understanding how the Court of Protection evaluates your capacity and decides what is best for you is key. The court follows clear rules to decide if you can make certain decisions and what happens if you cannot. This affects lasting power of attorney cases directly, especially when disputes arise.

Assessing Capacity and Mental Capacity Assessment

The court uses a strict test called the mental capacity assessment to decide if you lack the ability to make a specific decision when needed. This assessment looks at whether you can understand, retain, use or weigh information, and communicate your decision.

Capacity is decision-specific and may change over time. The court first checks if all steps have been taken to help you decide before concluding you lack capacity. This focus prevents unnecessary restrictions on your independence.

If you are found to lack capacity, the court may decide who should make decisions for you, including considering any lasting power of attorney you set up.

Best Interests Guidance

When you lack capacity, the court steps in to choose what is in your best interests. Best interests decisions consider your past and present wishes, feelings, beliefs, and values.

The court will also consider medical opinions, social circumstances, and any other relevant factors. They aim to make decisions that support your well-being and dignity, avoiding unnecessary restrictions like deprivation of liberty orders unless absolutely needed.

Your rights and preferences must be central, even if you cannot express them directly. The court ensures decisions are fair and proportionate to your situation.

Role of Litigation Friends and IMCAs

Litigation friends represent you in court if you cannot take part in proceedings yourself. They act in your best interests by helping present your case clearly and fairly.

Independent Mental Capacity Advocates (IMCAs) support you in important decisions, especially when there is no one else to speak for you. IMCAs provide expert, impartial views and make sure your wishes are heard.

Both help protect your rights during court processes related to lasting power of attorney and other decisions, ensuring your voice is not lost when you lack capacity.

Roles and Responsibilities of Deputies and Attorneys

When someone cannot make decisions for themselves, you might be asked to act as a deputy or attorney. You have clear duties linked to managing either property, finances, or personal welfare. Your role is to act in the person’s best interests and follow the law.

Types of Deputies: Property, Financial Affairs, and Personal Welfare

There are different types of deputies with specific responsibilities. A property and affairs deputy manages money, property, bills, and any financial decisions. This can include paying bills, collecting benefits, or selling property.

A personal welfare deputy makes decisions about health and welfare. This covers medical treatment, where a person lives, and their daily care. They cannot make decisions about marriage or voting.

You might be a professional deputy, appointed by the court because you have expertise, and you must follow strict rules. Deputies act only where lasting power of attorney (LPA) does not exist or is not valid.

Supervision of Attorneys and Deputies

Your work as a deputy or attorney is supervised to protect the person you support. The Court of Protection oversees deputies and can require regular reports on decisions and spending.

Attorneys must also follow the rules set out in the LPA and act honestly. If you fail in your duties, the court can remove you or take other actions.

The court’s supervision ensures you keep accurate records and act transparently. This guards against misuse of funds or poor decisions, keeping the person’s best interests at the heart of everything you do.

For detailed guidance, see LPAs, Court of Protection and deputies.

Common Scenarios and Outcomes in Court of Protection Cases

The Court of Protection often deals with complex situations involving personal welfare, finances, and legal disputes. You may face cases where family disagreements arise, issues with managing estates and wills occur, or concerns about a person's liberty and safety come into question.

Disputes Involving Family and Children

Family disputes in the Court of Protection often centre on decisions about adults who lack capacity or the welfare of children indirectly affected by those adults. You might see conflicts between relatives over who should make decisions about care, finances, or living arrangements.

The court’s role is to resolve disputes fairly, making decisions that protect vulnerable adults and children. If you are involved in a divorce or a civil partnership breakup where one party lacks capacity, the court can intervene to appoint a suitable decision-maker.

Your main concern should be proving the best interests and welfare of those involved. Often, judges insist on thorough reports from social workers or medical experts before deciding.

Wills, Probate, Trusts, and Estate Management

When an adult lacks mental capacity, managing their estate can become complicated. You might find yourself dealing with the Court of Protection to oversee wills, probate, or trusts, ensuring lawful handling of money and property.

You can apply for the court’s permission to manage these affairs if you hold a Lasting Power of Attorney (LPA) or if no LPA exists. The court supervises the management to prevent misuse of funds or assets.

If there are disagreements about how to use the estate or concerns about unfair treatment, the court will step in to protect the adult’s property. It can also make binding decisions on trusts or inheritance issues.

Deprivation of Liberty and Significant Harm Concerns

The court is often asked to make urgent decisions if you believe someone is at significant risk of harm or if their liberty is being restricted unlawfully. Deprivation of liberty means someone is being kept somewhere or controlled in a way they cannot leave freely, like in a care home.

If you are worried about such restrictions on an adult who lacks capacity, you can apply to the Court of Protection for an order authorising these steps legally. The court carefully balances safety with personal freedom.

In cases involving serious risks or harm, the court may appoint specific deputies to make decisions about care and treatment. You should be prepared to provide clear evidence showing why such measures are necessary.

Procedural Aspects and Recent Developments

You need to understand how the Court of Protection handles disputes and decisions in Lasting Power of Attorney (LPA) cases. Procedures include appeals, mediation options, emerging case law, and professional support that can help guide you through complex legal matters.

Appeals and the High Court

If you disagree with a decision made by the Court of Protection, you have the right to appeal. Appeals often go to the High Court, which reviews whether the original ruling was made correctly. It is important to act quickly as there are strict time limits for lodging an appeal.

The High Court examines points of law rather than revisiting all evidence. This means your appeal should focus on legal mistakes or errors in procedure. Getting legal advice early can help ensure your appeal is strong and within the legal framework.

Mediation and Alternative Dispute Resolution

Before going to a full court hearing, the Court of Protection encourages mediation or other forms of dispute resolution. Mediation allows you and other parties, such as attorneys or family members, to discuss issues with a neutral third party.

Using mediation can save time and fees. It also reduces stress compared to court proceedings. The Court supports mediation as a way to reach agreements without formal rulings, which can be particularly helpful in complex LPA disputes.

Emerging Case Law and Policy in England and Wales

Recent case law in England and Wales has clarified how the Court of Protection applies the Mental Capacity Act and deals with bespoke LPA clauses. Courts now pay close attention to ensuring that attorneys act within the scope of their powers.

New policies also focus on protecting vulnerable people from abuse or misuse of an LPA. There is a stronger emphasis on ensuring decisions reflect the donor’s best interests, which can affect how your case is handled if concerns arise.

Role of Professional Support, Including Duncan Lewis Solicitors

Professional support is critical when dealing with LPAs and the Court of Protection. Firms like Duncan Lewis Solicitors have expertise in mental capacity law and can guide you through procedural steps, applications, and disputes.

They can help prepare documents, represent you in court, and suggest strategies like mediation. This support reduces risks of errors and improves your chances of a positive outcome. You should consider legal professionals early in your case to navigate complex rules efficiently.

Want to know more?

Call us for a friendly chat on 02380 661 166 or email: info@apw-ifa.co.uk

Get In Touch
crossmenu